Skip to content
Faith in Theatres
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Home
  • About Faith
  • News, Reviews and Interviews
  • Promote Your Show
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
Drama, Review

Never the Sinner

24 Oct 2026

4 min read

Good Time Theatrics, Qtopia, The Loading Dock Theatre

Revisiting a Crime That Shocked Chicago: Feel Good Theatrics Puts Justice, Privilege and Retribution Under the Spotlight

When: 9- 24 Oct 2026

Two brilliant minds. One monstrous crime. A century of questions. John Logan’s Never the Sinner plunges into an infamous 1920s murder case, peeling back the sensational headlines to expose the warped logic of superiority, the seduction of power and the unsettling limits of accountability. Good Time Theatrics delivers a chilling psychological duel in the shadows of an inexplicable act of violence, where the line between fascination and revulsion blurs.

In 1924 Chicago, Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, two wealthy university students convinced they are above the law, kidnap and murder fourteen-year-old Bobby Franks in pursuit of the perfect crime. Through shifting timelines, interrogations and courtroom testimony, Logan reconstructs the case that gripped America, probing the psychology behind an act of calculated brutality. What makes a killer? Can we fathom such cold-blooded cruelty? And when the ultimate punishment is death, does justice prevail or does society simply sanction another killing?

The Loading Dock Theatre is perfect for this claustrophobic psychological drama. Its industrial confines evoke the pressure of the courtroom and the turmoil churning beneath the surface. Lighting designer Matthew Phillips’ stark spotlights and slashes of shadow sharpen the neo-noir aesthetic, while his sound design and composition heighten the menace and uncertainty. The audience becomes jury, witness and judge, while projected dates help orient us within the shifting timescape, as events jump backwards and forwards around the unfolding trial.

“Provocative, mesmerising and brilliantly executed, Never the Sinner leaves a chilling aftertaste.”

Plays based on true stories have a way of sending you straight to Google, and Never the Sinner is no exception. In 1924, both prosecution and defence drew on the era’s pathologising attitudes towards homosexuality when arguing over Leopold and Loeb’s mental state. That dimension of the trial sits largely outside this adaptation’s focus; exploring it fully would make for a very different play. Logan instead trains his sights on culpability, the psychology of evil and the morality of capital punishment. A century on, these questions of privilege, manipulation and justice feel sharply current in an age of celebrity worship and toxic masculinity, where entitlement masquerades as exceptionalism and the powerful can seem beyond consequences.

Director Kurtis Laing keeps the tension on a knife-edge, and the pressure mounting, the pace snapping between suspense, obsession and sensationalism, as Loeb and Leopold circle, stalk and goad one another and spirel further and further into their collective hubris. Peering into their warped psyches is as hypnotic as it is frightening.

Josh Hammond and Jack Bridges wrestle with a toxic attraction in a mesmerising game of dominance and delusion. Hammond is combustible as Loeb, his maniacal smile masking a chilling amorality, with barely contained violence simmering beneath the surface. Bridges’ Leopold is cold, cerebral and controlled, until cracks appear in his icy composure. It’s a brilliant pairing, their contrasting energies creating a magnetic push and pull of who’s manipulating whom? Both actors are nothing short of electric, seducing the audience as readily as they seduce each other. Convinced they’re masters of the game, they never see the catastrophe their arrogance sets in motion.

The psychology of cruelty, the seduction of power and the cost of arrogance.
The courtroom becomes a battleground for competing versions of truth and justice.

The courtroom clashes crackle as justice takes centre stage. Veteran actor Mark Langham is superb as defence lawyer Clarence Darrow, bringing measured authority and steely conviction to Darrow’s formidable defense and intellect, while Harlee Timms imbues prosecutor Robert Crowe with tenacity and passion.Their adversarial exchanges pit legal principle against moral outrage, each making a compelling case and forcing us to weigh the arguments and consequences of justice, retribution and the death penalty.

Witnesses, doctors and reporters converge as the trial becomes a media circus. Alex Travers, Frey Kenay and Lala Chesterman bring exceptional pace and versatility to a succession of quick-change roles. Seamlessly narrating events while embodying the chaotic swarm of journalists and psychological experts, the trio expertly capture the public frenzy that threatens to overshadow the truth.

A century on, Leopold and Loeb are long gone, but the questions remain: how does privilege distort a sense of right and wrong? Can we comprehend cruelty without excusing it? And when justice demands punishment, who gets the final say? The verdict is history. The argument is far from over.

Provocative. Mesmerising and brilliantly executed, Never the Sinner leaves a chilling aftertaste. If you love true crime, prepare to have your assumptions challenged. If you’ve never been drawn to courtroom dramas, this might be the case that changes your mind.

Never the Sinner closes Saturday 24 October Qtopia Sydney. For further details see ;https://tickets.qtopiasydney.com.au/Events/Never-the-Sinner/

Think you’ve got a verdict? Follow Faith in Theatres on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok for more reviews, revelations and theatrical cases worth arguing about.

Because theatre – needs Faith

Photo Credit: Jack Shep

Back to News, Reviews and Interviews

© Copyright 2026 Faith in Theatres by Faith Jessel